The Tear Garden - The Brown Acid Caveat - Albums - Reviews - Soundblab

The Tear Garden - The Brown Acid Caveat

by Jim Harris Rating:6 Release Date:2017-07-07

Somewhere in the dark and dreary corners of my basement, along with spiders, unsold books, broken zip drives and hundreds of miscellaneous cords that plug into all sorts of devices no longer around, I have a cassette of The Legendary Pink Dots.  The name stuck but the music I cannot recall. 

Now supposedly the new release, The Brown Acid Caveat by the Tear Garden has a member from this band and a member from Skinny Puppy.  I have no Skinny Puppy music in my collection even though I spent around six years writing reviews for the London-based dark techno, electronica magazine, and now-defunct Subculture.  Skinny Puppy always seemed to have a sound that screamed, “You have to be there!”  I never went there and never got to see them in concert.

But both of these bands have a solid cult following, I believe.  The Tear Garden is a side project for these two people from these two respective bands.  The music is heavy on the electronics, and the ominous inflected voice of the lead singer trudges his way through dark and shocking lyrics and occasional flights of experimental talk-sing to evoke sinister and dark musical extravaganzas that occasionally have a touch of humor punctuating them.   But only occasionally. 

The electronica and mixes here are often quite strong and interesting.  ‘Strange Land’ start things off nicely and more often than not the music, when not being experimentally pacing things, works very well.

The Tear Garden have never toured and it might have to do with the pacing and structure of the songs.  It’s much less manically dramatic than Skinny Puppy and occasionally slips into mere story telling with a bit of background noise.

The lyrical content is where I get bogged down.  Quietly ominous themes of death and stalking, mutilation and pedophilia, mad scientist shit, most of the songs tell somewhat uninteresting stories from my perspective as a listener.  It ultimately has the same yawning eye-rolling effect on me that has kept Skinny Puppy at bay from my collection.

But I would suspect listeners enthralled by Skinny Puppy or any number of the grotesque chew up a dead rat and show it gleaming on your tongue brand of electronica told at a slower pace and more experimentally quiet manner, might really appreciate The Tear Garden.

It’s just not my cup of tea and the music isn’t sustainably listenable to not focus on the lyrical content for extended replays.  But as a side project it probably functions at some level of satisfaction to get these types of songs out of their system.  Or revitalize their system.  Regardless if you are so inclined of such dark experimental electronica, have at it.

Comments (10)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

writing a review for something you know nothing about is so stupid. I and many others would seriously like to know just what makes you think you are qualified to even write anything about something you are clueless about. stick to writing about...

writing a review for something you know nothing about is so stupid. I and many others would seriously like to know just what makes you think you are qualified to even write anything about something you are clueless about. stick to writing about nicklesback or whatever "SHIT" you like to listen to.

Read More
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Why on earth are you specifically reviewing this album? You state you dislike the genre and invariably you concluded nothing more than it reflects your outlook on the genre. You're a horrible reviewer and the editor that would present this to the...

Why on earth are you specifically reviewing this album? You state you dislike the genre and invariably you concluded nothing more than it reflects your outlook on the genre. You're a horrible reviewer and the editor that would present this to the public to review should be ashamed.

Read More
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Jim,

I actually like your review quite a bit. There is so much mediocre music out there it's nice to have a reviewer willing to separate the wheat from the chaff. Now I know I can skip this one and not feel like I'm missing out. Thanks, man!

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Agreed, Jon. I'm not sure what all the fuss is about. The album is given a 6, a pretty solid grade. Take it from a teacher - not everything is an 8 or above, and 6 is a decent grade. Also, the fact that Jim states he's not a fan of the genre...

Agreed, Jon. I'm not sure what all the fuss is about. The album is given a 6, a pretty solid grade. Take it from a teacher - not everything is an 8 or above, and 6 is a decent grade. Also, the fact that Jim states he's not a fan of the genre gives him valuable perspective the fan-boys clearly lack.

Read More
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

One thing I do want to clarify is I didn't actually say I'm not a fan of the genre. I'm a huge fan. (Combichrist is perhaps my favorite). I truly thought since I find Skinny Puppy not as good as who they influence, this side project would be...

One thing I do want to clarify is I didn't actually say I'm not a fan of the genre. I'm a huge fan. (Combichrist is perhaps my favorite). I truly thought since I find Skinny Puppy not as good as who they influence, this side project would be more interesting.

Read More
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

You, the next time Skinny Puppy comes on...

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Up until this point I didn't realize the review was supposed to be satire. Nice one. (For those unfamiliar with the topic, this is akin to saying "I love literature, 50 Shades of Grey is my favourite book, but I could never really get into this...

Up until this point I didn't realize the review was supposed to be satire. Nice one. (For those unfamiliar with the topic, this is akin to saying "I love literature, 50 Shades of Grey is my favourite book, but I could never really get into this García Márquez person she was apparently inspired by".

Read More
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

E.L James and Marquez are both dense. Kind of like fanboy commentary.

There are no comments posted here yet